The Smell of an Election: Lagos Debates Waste, Water, and Who Will Finally Clean it Up
By Oluwaseyi Elizabeth Jimoh
Lagos does not so much manage its waste as move it out of sight. At a debate for the 2027 governorship, four men offered four different explanations for why.
On a humid evening in Lagos, the question was not whether the city smells. Everyone in the room knew that it does, in places. The question was why — and whose fault it is that a city of more than twenty million people, a city that styles itself as Africa’s economic capital, still has no coherent answer for what to do with what it throws away.
The debate, organised by Channels Television, Television Continental, Punch, TheCable and Vanguard, was meant to be a preview of the 2027 governorship election. But for much of the night, it became something more elemental: a reckoning with water and waste, the two forces that most shape daily life in Lagos and most expose the limits of its government.
Gbadebo Rhodes-Vivour, the aspirant for the African Democratic Congress, was the most unsparing. He did not call Lagos’s system broken. He called it something else entirely: not a system at all.
“We don’t have a waste management system; we only have a pick-and-dump system,” he said.
It was a line delivered without flourish, which made it land harder. In his telling, Lagos has centralised waste collection to the point of paralysis, sidelined the local governments that should be closest to the problem, and failed — spectacularly — to build what almost every modern city now treats as basic: a waste-to-wealth value chain, and a waste-to-energy value chain.
He invoked a kind of lost golden age. Under Babatunde Fashola, he said, roughly a thousand waste trucks were on the road. Now, there are about two hundred. Population has grown. The fleet has shrunk. The arithmetic, he suggested, explains the smell.
His alternative was decentralisation, almost old-fashioned in its simplicity: let households separate waste at source. Let local governments collect it. Let different trucks take different kinds of waste to different kinds of facilities — recycling for what can be recycled, processing for what can be processed, energy for what can be burned for power. Everyone, he argued, would benefit: the resident who sorts, the local government that collects, the state that no longer pays to bury value in the ground.
He was also careful to reject an easy excuse. Lagos’s problems, he said, cannot be blamed on population alone, and certainly not solved by telling people to go back to wherever they came from. A city is not a village that got too big. It is a system that either works, or does not.
Dr. Obafemi Hamzat, the aspirant for the All Progressives Congress, the party that has governed Lagos for a quarter-century, did not dispute the scale of the problem. Lagos generates a staggering volume of waste, he conceded, and it has almost nowhere to put it. The state’s landmass is small. Its dumps are large. Its options are few.
But he insisted that a transition is under way — from collection-and-dumping to collection-and-recovery. He pointed to facilities planned for Olusosun and Alimosho, the two names that have come to stand in for Lagos’s waste crisis. Recover 10,000 units of waste, he said, and the city begins to turn a corner.
It was the language of continuity: not a repudiation, but a refinement. The system is not wrong, only unfinished.
Funso Doherty, of the Nigeria Democratic Congress, would have none of it. A Lagosian himself, he admitted that the admission pained him.
“As a Lagosian, it is very difficult for me to admit that Lagos is smelling,” he said, “but I am sure that some parts of Lagos are smelling and some parts are also clean. But we certainly have a waste management problem, and again, I will characterise this as a failure of governance.”
For Doherty, the failure is both immediate and long-term. In the short term, Lagos does not have enough trucks, or enough receiving vehicles at transfer stations, to pick up the waste it already produces. In the long term, it has not built the recycling and waste-to-power infrastructure that would make collection worthwhile. You cannot recycle what you never collect. You cannot generate power from waste that is still rotting on the street.
Adedeji Doherty, of the Peoples Democratic Party, took the argument back to capacity. The population has grown, he said, but the vehicles have not. And waste, he reminded the room, is not one thing. There is solid waste, liquid waste, human waste — each requiring a different kind of management, each currently failing in its own way. He pointed, in particular, to Olusosun, whose pollution has become a byword for environmental neglect.
If waste was the first act, flooding was the second — and, in Lagos, the two are never really separate. A blocked drain is a flood waiting for rain. A flooded street is a waste dump that has come back to find you.
Here, too, Rhodes-Vivour reached for vision. He spoke of Japan and the Netherlands, countries that have learned to live with water rather than fight it. He spoke of urban planning as a moral act. And he warned, pointedly, about the sandfilling of waterfront communities like Makoko, and the destruction of wetlands and natural channels. Build over the places where water is supposed to go, he said, and the water will go somewhere else — usually into someone’s home.
Hamzat, again, offered a more technical diagnosis. Rainfall, he said, has increased — from 2.2 to 2.7, by his figures — putting new pressure on drains built for a different climate. The solution, in his view, is better evacuation: move the water faster toward the creeks and lagoons that have always been Lagos’s natural release valves.
Doherty pushed back on climate as alibi. Flooding in Lagos, he argued, cannot be attributed to climate change alone. The state has allowed wetlands to be destroyed and waterways to be built upon. It has failed to enforce its own environmental regulations. He questioned whether a proper Environmental Impact Assessment was conducted before work began on the Lagos-Calabar Coastal Road — a project that has become, for critics, a symbol of building first and asking later.
Hamzat disagreed. An assessment was conducted, he said, with attention paid to water movement.
And there, for a moment, the debate stalled — as debates about Lagos often do — between two competing stories: one in which the city is a victim of forces larger than itself, and one in which it is the author of its own drowning.
What emerged, over the course of the evening, was not consensus but a taxonomy of failure. For Rhodes-Vivour, it is a failure of design: too centralised, too unimaginative. For Hamzat, it is a failure of transition: a system in the middle of becoming something better. For the two Dohertys, it is a failure of governance: the state knows what to do, and has not done it.
The audience was left with the smell, and the rain, and the knowledge that in Lagos, both will return.





Comments